Why Magisk Over SuperSU for Rooting your Android Device?

Magisk has a few advantages over SuperSU, but the most important is that Magisk doesn’t have any binaries. This means it will not instigate malicious events with its operation and can be easily rooted with just one click of your mouse.

Magisk is a popular alternative to SuperSU. Magisk Manager is the best way to install magisk on your device. It allows you to easily manage and update magisk, as well as configure it for optimal performance.

SuperSU vs. Magisk

-Advertisements-

AMD against Intel, Android vs iOS, Nvidia vs Radeon, and now Magisk vs SuperSu are just a few of the tech industry’s conflicts. Which is the superior option? Which route should you take? Let’s go right to the point and pit Magisk against Supersu to determine who has the upper hand.

SuperSu has been around for a long time, while Magisk is very young in comparison to SuperSu. Both of these methods will now root your smartphone. However, everyone has an own working style.

SuperSu

By entirely modifying certain system files and even adding files to the system disk, you may stop security checks like as SafetyNet Status and Forced Encryptions, which means banking apps and apps like Android Pay and Netflix will no longer run on your smartphone.

Magisk

on the other hand, has you covered for all of SupeSu’s flaws. It just changes the boot image to a magisk image (boot.img to magisk.img) and leaves the system and partition alone. This is referred to as “systemless root.” This not only helps to maintain SafetyNet Status, but it can also be used to implement forced encryption via the Magisk Manager tool. Magisk also allows you to conceal root from certain apps, allowing you to use banking, Netflix, and other apps even if your device is rooted.

Okay, we realize that was a lot of technical jargon in a short period of time. Allow me to explain. Starting with System partitions, your Android device’s internal storage is separated or, to put it another way, partitioned into several segments like as

/boot
/system
/recovery
/sdcard
/misc
/cache, for example.

Each division has a distinct function that is very self-explanatory. Without the ramdisk and kernel in the /boot partition, the device would not start at all. The recovery partition offers enough space for the device to have its own recovery or enhanced recovery. The Operating System is included in the system recovery.

SuperSu’s modification of the partition causes the SafetyNet Check to fail. What exactly is SafetyNet?

API for SafetyNet

is intended to detect if a device has been tampered with, such as by a user rooting it, installing a custom ROM, or being infected with low-level malware.

Google’s Android “Compatibility Test Suite” must be passed by devices that arrive with Google’s Play Store and other applications installed. A device cannot be “CTS Compatible” if it has been rooted or has a custom ROM installed. The SafetyNet API uses this method to determine whether or not you are rooted; it just checks for CTS compatibility. Similarly, even if you do not attempt to root your smartphone, an Android device that never came with Google’s applications, such as those cheap unbranded Chinese handsets, will not be deemed CTS compliant.

Google Play Services installs and executes an application called “snet” in the background on your device to get this information. The app gathers information from your smartphone and transmits it to Google on a regular basis. This information is used by Google for a number of objectives, including gaining a better understanding of the Android ecosystem and assessing whether or not your device’s software has been tampered with. Google doesn’t say what snet is searching for, but it’s probable that it’s checking to see whether your system partition has been changed from its factory state. In summary, breaking Google’s security conventions by causing the SafetyNet API to fail would prevent you from accessing certain applications that check for SafetyNet status.

Now here is when Magisk has the upper hand. Remember how we said Magick has a systemless root and does not change the system? This implies that you can keep your SafetyNet status with Magisk while still being able to utilize applications that check for it. Despite the fact that SuperSu has evolved over time and now has the ability to conceal root from particular applications, SafetyNet remains a major question mark for SuperSu since it still alters the system for rooted. So you’ve probably figured out why we prefer Magisk over SuperSu.

Magisk’s advantages vs SuperSu

Also, Magisk has its own library of modules that are maintained by our talented engineers; these modules are comparable to Xposed Modules, however Magisk modules are not backward compatible with Xposed Modules, thus you won’t be able to use Xposed Modules with Magisk. And if you absolutely need an Xposed Module, Magisk’s library has grown to the point where you’ll be able to locate a comparable module in Magisk that accomplishes the same thing. With Magisk, you should no longer utilize an Xposed framework. Why are you interrogating me? The entire objective of Magisk was to prevent system change and maintain SafetyNet Status, yet Xposed Framework affects the system, causing the SafetyNet Status tests to fail.

Google, on the other hand, has been diligent in maintaining the SafetyNet API and has even restricted its use after systemless root. However, our Magisk engineers are always trying to improve Magisk and pass SafetyNet after systemless roots. Between the two of them, it’s a cat-and-mouse game!

Magisk is a root solution that works on more devices than SuperSU. It’s also compatible with the latest Android Oreo release. Reference: how to install magisk.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I replace SuperSU with Magisk?

A: Magisk is a substitute for SuperSU, but does not replace it.

Does installing Magisk root your device?

A: Yes.

Is rooting with Magisk safe?

A: Yes, Magisk is safe to root with. Its always best practice to make sure your computer is fully up-to-date before you attempt any rooting methods though.